Several of the major characters in the After series were surprisingly (and perhaps confusingly) recast for After We Fell, and there were a few things that factored into the cast shuffle for the third movie. Though the turbulent teen romance did retain its two lead lovers, complications caused many actors to be unable to participate in not only After We Fell but also its upcoming sequel, After Ever Happy. Unfortunately, their unavailability was outside any one person’s control and will have an impact on the rest of the film series.
After We Fell picks up immediately after the events of After We Collided. Publishing intern Tessa Young, played by Josephine Langford, finally gets a chance to connect with her father, who also has an impact on her boyfriend, Hardin Scott (Hero Fiennes-Tiffin). Hardin continues to work through the conflicts of his family, his anger, and his relationship with Tessa. With Hardin’s mother’s wedding on the horizon, Hardin and Tessa continue to learn more about the secrets their families hide and who they want to be for each other.
Indirect complications due to the Covid-19 pandemic were responsible for the mass recasting for After We Fell. While the previous films were primarily shot in Atlanta, Georgia, filming for After We Fell took place in Sofia, Bulgaria, unluckily happening right at the height of the pandemic. As international travel precautions and guidelines had greatly changed, many actors’ ability to be on-site was impeded. Additionally, After We Fell was shot concurrently with its sequel, After Ever Happy. This extended the film shoot’s schedule significantly, causing conflict with some actors’ other projects.
In total, five major roles in After We Fell were recast. Landon Gibson, Hardin’s considerate step-brother, was originally played by Shane Paul McGhie but now is embodied by Chance Perdomo, who audiences will know from his time as one of Chilling Adventures of Sabrina‘s main characters, Ambrose. Candice King was replaced as publishing secretary Kimberly Vance by Arielle Kebbel. The character’s husband, publishing mogul Christian Vance, is now played by Stephen Moyer, though originally by Charlie Weber. Selma Blair’s role as Carol Young, Tessa’s mother, was taken up by Mira Sorvino, and Karimah Westbrook’s Karen Scott, Hardin’s mother, is now played by Frances Turner.
While it’s unfortunate many adored actors were unable to return for After We Fell, the new cast retains much of the spirit of the previous films. Tessa and Hardin’s whirlwind romance manages to continue with the same infectious spark, and the cast handles the darkness inherent to their love more dramatically than ever. Guaranteed to return for Ever After Happy, the cast of After We Fell is just what the After series needs.